Sherlock Holmes: the birth of the greatest detective

A thin man in a dressing gown examines a smear of mud on a shoe through a magnifying glass. In seconds, he tells his astonished visitor his profession, his recent journey and his mood that morning. The visitor has not yet said a word. In the smoke-filled sitting room of 221B Baker Street, a piece of reasoning has just turned trivial details into truth. This is the magic of Sherlock Holmes.

Sherlock Holmes is a fictional detective created by the Scottish writer Arthur Conan Doyle, first appearing in 1887. Across four novels and fifty-six short stories, the character became the absolute archetype of the detective: the man who sees what others merely look at. More than a century later, he remains one of the most adapted fictional characters in the world.

A detective born in Edinburgh#

Sherlock Holmes was born from the pen of a Scottish doctor. Arthur Conan Doyle (1859-1930), trained in medicine at the University of Edinburgh, published A Study in Scarlet in 1887, in Beeton's Christmas Annual. Success was not immediate; it came with the short stories published in the Strand Magazine from 1891, devoured by a whole readership.

The real-life model for the detective was one of Doyle's teachers: Doctor Joseph Bell, a surgeon in Edinburgh, able to guess a patient's trade and history simply by observing him. Doyle, who had been his assistant, transposed this clinical sharpness into a method of detection. Holmes is no magician: he turns on crime the gaze of a doctor on a body.

Holmes does not guess: he observes what everyone sees, and deduces what no one thinks to conclude.

The method: observe, deduce, solve#

What sets Holmes apart is his method. Where the official police go astray, he starts from the tiniest detail — a scratch, a fold of a sleeve, cigar ash — to trace back, through a chain of reasoning, to the culprit. Doyle calls it "deduction"; logicians rather recognise abduction, the art of forming the best hypothesis from clues.

This rigour would not shine the same way without his indispensable companion. Doctor John Watson, a former military surgeon back from Afghanistan, shares the Baker Street flat and narrates the cases. Narrator and foil, he asks the questions the reader is asking, and allows Holmes — and so Doyle — to explain his method without ever seeming pedantic.

Baker Street and its gallery of figures#

Holmes's world owes as much to its characters as to its puzzles. At 221B Baker Street, the London address that became a myth, watches the landlady Mrs Hudson. At Scotland Yard, Inspector Lestrade embodies the competent but outpaced police. And in the shadows lurks Professor Moriarty, the "Napoleon of crime," an enemy worthy of the hero: a mind as brilliant as his own, but turned toward evil.

As for Holmes's most famous attributes — the deerstalker cap, the curved pipe, the magnifying glass — they owe less to the novels than to Sidney Paget's illustrations in the Strand and, later, to cinema. Likewise, the line "Elementary, my dear Watson," so bound up with the character, never appears as such in Doyle's writings: it is an invention of posterity.

The hero who refused to die#

In 1893, Doyle, weary of a character that he felt eclipsed his "serious" works, decided to kill him. In The Final Problem, he hurls Holmes and Moriarty into the Reichenbach Falls in Switzerland, locked in a fatal struggle. The public reaction was unprecedented: readers went into mourning, thousands cancelled their subscription to the Strand.

Under pressure, Doyle finally resurrected his detective. In 1901 came The Hound of the Baskervilles (an adventure set before the fall), then, in 1903, The Empty House explained that Holmes had faked his death. The hero was too alive to die: his creator had to bow to him.

An endless legacy#

Sherlock Holmes is today one of the most adapted characters in history: films, series, pastiches and reinventions number in the hundreds, from the Victorian Holmes to contemporary versions transposed to London or New York. He fixed forever the codes of the crime novel: the brilliant detective, the narrating companion, the locked-room puzzle, the final revelation.

From the Baker Street sitting room to screens the world over, Holmes taught generations of readers to truly look — to turn a smear, a silence, a detail into meaning. To discover him is to learn to read the world as a puzzle; and to learn English is to be able to hear Doyle in the text, catch the elegant dryness of Holmes and savour the quiet irony of Watson.

FAQ#

Who created Sherlock Holmes? Sherlock Holmes was created by the Scottish writer Arthur Conan Doyle (1859-1930), a doctor by training. The detective first appears in 1887 in the novel A Study in Scarlet, then in a long series of short stories published in the Strand Magazine.

Where does Sherlock Holmes live? Sherlock Holmes lives at 221B Baker Street, in London, where he shares a flat with Doctor Watson, under the care of the landlady Mrs Hudson. This fictional address became so famous that it now houses a museum dedicated to the character.

Does Holmes really say "Elementary, my dear Watson"? No. The phrase "Elementary, my dear Watson" appears as such in none of Conan Doyle's novels or short stories. Holmes does say "elementary" and does call Watson "my dear Watson," but never in that exact sentence: it was born from later adaptations.

Who is Professor Moriarty? Professor Moriarty is Sherlock Holmes's great enemy, nicknamed the "Napoleon of crime." A criminal genius as intelligent as the detective, he confronts him in The Final Problem, where the two men fall together into the Reichenbach Falls.

Photo credits: the images used in this article come from Pexels and Unsplash and are royalty-free.